American Horror Story Recast Fan Casting Poster

Fan CastingAmerican Horror Story Recast

What if an actor played each individual role?

by Ryan Murphy

Story added by jazzyjayne23 on July 15, 2020

Do not add the same actor/actress from one role onto another. I don't want the same actor to be multiple roles (ex. Dylan O'Brien as the top choice for Kit Walker, Dandy, and Tate Langdon). Let's be super creative here!read more

read synopsis

#ahs #americanhorrorstory #evanpeters #tatelangdon #murderhouse #asylum #coven #freakshow #hotel #roanoke #horror #noir #america #war

< back to story

Suggest Actors to Play Dell Toledo(Freak Show)

Who do you think should play Dell Toledo? Use the form to the rightbelow to find the perfect actor for this role!

Find an Actor

Dell Toledo
Bryan Cranston
68 years old Suggest
John Goodman
71 years old Suggested
Hugh Jackman
55 years old Suggest
Anthony Hopkins
86 years old Suggest
Josh Brolin
56 years old Suggest
Jack Black
54 years old Suggest
David Harbour
49 years old Suggest
John Cena
47 years old Suggest
Tom Hardy
46 years old Suggest
Dwayne Johnson
51 years old Suggest
Danny DeVito
79 years old Suggest
John C. Reilly
58 years old Suggest
Mark Hamill
72 years old Suggest
J.K. Simmons
69 years old Suggest
Alfred Molina
70 years old Suggest
Jeff Bridges
74 years old Suggest
Tom Hanks
67 years old Suggest
Willem Dafoe
68 years old Suggest
Robert De Niro
80 years old Suggest
Jason Momoa
44 years old Suggest
Seth Rogen
42 years old Suggest
Idris Elba
51 years old Suggest
Gary Oldman
66 years old Suggest

Filter

Find someone for this role:

Minimum Age

Maximum Age

Gender

Category

Hair Color

Hair Length

Eye Color

Minimum Height

Maximum Height

Ethnicity

Body Type

Facial Hair

Nationality

Reset Search

Newest Stories

Ready to move onto another story? Here are a few more to browse. Assemble your dream cast!

See More