Fan Casting American Horror Story Recast
What if an actor played each individual role?
by Ryan Murphy
Story added by jazzyjayne23 on July 15, 2020
Story Plot
Do not add the same actor/actress from one role onto another. I don't want the same actor to be multiple roles (ex. Dylan O'Brien as the top choice for Kit Walker, Dandy, and Tate Langdon). Let's be super creative here!
Contribute
Fan Casting Roles for American Horror Story Recast
-
Madison Montgomery (Coven & Apocalypse)
Top suggestion out of 27
Madison Iseman
Cast Your Vote -
Zoe Benson (Coven & Apocalypse)
Top suggestion out of 19
Maya Hawke
Cast Your Vote -
The Countess (Hotel)
Top suggestion out of 23
Cate Blanchett
Cast Your Vote -
Violet Harmon (Murder House)
Top suggestion out of 18
Anya Taylor-Joy
Cast Your Vote -
Tate Langdon (Murder House)
Top suggestion out of 17
Bill Skarsgård
Cast Your Vote -
Hypodermic Sally (Hotel)
Top suggestion out of 16
Natasha Lyonne
Cast Your Vote -
Constance Langdon (Murder House)
Top suggestion out of 12
Michelle Pfeiffer
Cast Your Vote -
Brooke Thompson (1984)
Top suggestion out of 18
Daisy Edgar-Jones
Cast Your Vote -
Ben Harmon (Murder House)
Top suggestion out of 23
Patrick Dempsey
Cast Your Vote -
Montana Duke (1984)
Top suggestion out of 17
Sydney Sweeney
Cast Your Vote -
Marie Laveau (Coven)
Top suggestion out of 15
Naomie Harris
Cast Your Vote -
Myrtle Snow (Coven & Apocalypse)
Top suggestion out of 11
Tilda Swinton
Cast Your Vote -
Jimmy Darling (Freak Show)
Top suggestion out of 10
Jeremy Allen White
Cast Your Vote -
Sister Mary Eunice McKee (Asylum)
Top suggestion out of 11
Lucy Boynton
Cast Your Vote -
Vivien Harmon (Murder House)
Top suggestion out of 14
Drew Barrymore
Cast Your Vote -
Sister Jude Martin (Asylum)
Top suggestion out of 11
Gillian Anderson
Cast Your Vote -
Moira O'Hara (Young) (Murder House)
Top suggestion out of 11
Haley Bennett
Cast Your Vote -
Margaret Kirchner (1984)
Top suggestion out of 12
Milla Jovovich
Cast Your Vote -
Kyle Spencer (Coven)
Top suggestion out of 13
Brandon Flynn
Cast Your Vote -
Cordelia Foxx (Coven & Apocalypse)
Top suggestion out of 10
Keira Knightley
Cast Your Vote
Join myCast
Do you love movies? Fan casting? myCast is the place for you!
Join thousands of other users in fan casting your favorite stories. Take 30 seconds to create a completely free profile, which will allow you to:
- Add your own stories and characters
- Make casting suggestions
- Vote and comment on casting suggestions
- Add and edit talent profiles
- Post to the forums
Need an account?
Create a free account
Join myCast
Do you love movies? Fan casting? myCast is the place for you!
Join thousands of other users in fan casting your favorite stories. Take 30 seconds to create a completely free profile, which will allow you to:
- Add your own stories and characters
- Make casting suggestions
- Vote and comment on casting suggestions
- Add and edit talent profiles
- Post to the forums
Join the Conversation