Suggestions by @michaelzilla

Michael B. Jordan

as Glamrock Freddy in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +1

Dwayne Johnson

as Montgomery Gator in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +1

Zachary Levi

as Funtime Freddy in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +1

Jodi Benson

as Withered Chica in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +1

John Amos

as Ignited Freddy in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +1

Matthew Lillard

as Wiliam Afton in Five Nights at freddys 4 : the final chapter

Score: +2

Shemar Moore

as Nightmare Fredbear in Five Nights at freddys 4 : the final chapter

Score: -1

Halle Bailey

as Glamrock Chica in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +1

Billy Dee Williams

as Withered Golden Freddy in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +1

Jensen Ackles

as Withered Foxy in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +1

Matt Damon

as Withered Bonnie in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +1

Denzel Washington

as Withered Freddy in FNAF Animatronics

Score: -1

Linden Porco

as Cupcake in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +1

Sam Riegel

as Puppet in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +1

Lin-Manuel Miranda

as Candy in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +1

Tobey Maguire

as Frankburt in FNAF Animatronics

Score: -1

Warwick Davis

as Nightmare Cupcake in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +1

Jon Huertas

as Nightmare Foxy in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +1

Mandy Moore

as Nightmare Chica in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +1

Chris Sullivan

as Nightmare Bonnie in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +1