Suggestions by @michaelzilla

Shaquille O'Neal

as Ignited Golden Freddy in FNAF Animatronics

Jack Davenport

as Tortured Device in FNAF Animatronics

Carl Weathers

as Tortured Freddy in FNAF Animatronics

Chris Brown

as Chuck E. Cheese in FNAF Animatronics

Javier Bardem

as Nightmare Fredbear in FNAF Animatronics

Daveed Diggs

as Fatz Geronimo in FNAF Animatronics

Hugh Jackman

as Foxy in FNAF Animatronics

Chris Pine

as Frankburt in FNAF Animatronics

Dave Franco

as Ignited Foxy in FNAF Animatronics

Katherine McNamara

as Chica in FNAF Animatronics

Ryan Reynolds

as Vigo in FNAF Animatronics

Jonathan Majors

as Withered Freddy in FNAF Animatronics

Benedict Cumberbatch

as Nightmare Springtrap in FNAF Animatronics

Jim Carrey

as Ignited Bonnie in FNAF Animatronics

Anika Noni Rose

as Happy Frog in FNAF Animatronics

Tobey Maguire

as Frankburt in The Return to Freddy's

Kathryn Newton

as Circus Baby in FNAF Animatronics

Tom Hiddleston

as Glamrock Foxy in FNAF Animatronics

Angela Bassett

as Roxanne Wolf in FNAF Animatronics

Paul Rudd

as Glamrock Bonnie in FNAF Animatronics