Suggestions by @michaelzilla

Sterling K. Brown

as Nightmare Golden Freddy in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +1

Winston Duke

as Nightmare Freddy in FNAF Animatronics

Score: -1

Louis Gossett Jr.

as Nightmare in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +1

James Earl Jones

as Nightmare in FNAF Animatronics

Score: -1

Shemar Moore

as Nightmare Fredbear in FNAF Animatronics

Score: -1

Alice Hunter

as Mangle in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +1

Ariana Grande

as Toy Chica in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +1

Ben Schwartz

as Toy Bonnie in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +1

Don Cheadle

as Toy Freddy in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +1

Edward Norton

as Phantom Bonnie in FNAF Animatronics

Score: -1

Lena Headey

as Phantom Chica in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +1

Idris Elba

as Phantom Freddy in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +1

Pete Davidson

as Phantom Foxy in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +1

Tom Holland

as Balloon Boy in FNAF Animatronics

Score: 0

Wesley Snipes

as Springtrap in FNAF Animatronics

Score: -1

Morgan Freeman

as Golden Freddy in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +1

Josh Brolin

as Creation in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +1

Whitney Peak

as Chica in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +1

Lou Ferrigno Jr.

as Bonnie in FNAF Animatronics

Score: +1

Tony Todd

as Freddy in FNAF Animatronics

Score: 0