Fan Casting Jennie Garth as Carly Whittaker in How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)

chris83 made this fan casting suggestion on March 7, 2022. What do you think? See below to cast your vote, or click here to see all fan casting suggestions for this role.

Jennie Garth as Carly Whittaker in How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)

Jennie Garth

52 years old

Jennifer Eve "Jennie" Garth is an American actress and film director, best known for starring as Kelly Taylor throughout the Beverly Hills, 90210 franchise and Valerie Tyler on the sitcom What I Li...

See Profile

Loading another FastCast...

Carly Whittaker in How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)

add character image

Fan Casting

Jennie Garth

as

Carly Whittaker

in

How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)

Do you agree?

Vote Yes Vote No

How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)

How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)

Twenty years earlier

by CBS

A father recounts to his children - through a series of flashbacks - the journey he and his four best friends took leading up to him meeting their mother.

See Story

Has this person been officially cast for this role? Click here.

Fan casting suggestion made by:

Join the Conversation

0 comments on Jennie Garth as Carly Whittaker in How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)

Jennie Garth is known for her roles in Family Guy Presents Stewie Griffin: The Untold Story, Karen Kingsbury's A Time to Dance, and Holidaze. She has been suggested by fans for 209 roles on myCast, including Coco St. Pierre Vanderbilt in American Horror Story Recast. Similar actors include Cameron Diaz, Sarah Michelle Gellar, and Alicia Silverstone. Jennie Garth was suggested to play Carly Whittaker in How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994) by chris83. Other actors sugggested to play this role include Jodie Foster, Laura Dern, and Heather Graham. How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994) has 51 roles, including Heather Mosby, Katie Scherbatsky, and Robin Scherbatsky.

Supporters (2)

Opposers (1)

krmickey97

More Fan Casting Suggestions for Carly Whittaker in How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)

Sheryl Lee

Sheryl Lee

as

Carly Whittaker

in

How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)

3 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)
Kelly Ripa

Kelly Ripa

as

Carly Whittaker

in

How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)

2 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)
Shannon Sturges

Shannon Sturges

as

Carly Whittaker

in

How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)

2 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)
Melinda Clarke

Melinda Clarke

as

Carly Whittaker

in

How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)

2 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)
Charlotte Ross

Charlotte Ross

as

Carly Whittaker

in

How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)

2 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)
Patricia Arquette

Patricia Arquette

as

Carly Whittaker

in

How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)
Jane Krakowski

Jane Krakowski

as

Carly Whittaker

in

How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)
Erika Eleniak

Erika Eleniak

as

Carly Whittaker

in

How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)

1 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

How I Met Your Mother (1985-1994)

Newest Stories

Ready to move onto another story? Here are a few more to browse. Assemble your dream cast!

See More