Fan Casting Jay Baruchel as Jeff Pfister in American Horror Story Recast

jazzyjayne23 made this fan casting suggestion on July 15, 2020. What do you think? See below to cast your vote, or click here to see all fan casting suggestions for this role.

Jay Baruchel as Jeff Pfister in American Horror Story Recast

Jay BaruchelCanada

42 years old
Jonathan Adam Saunders Baruchel (born April 9, 1982) is a Canadian actor. He has had a successful career in comedy films, and has appeared in such box office successes as Million Dollar Baby, Knock...
See Profile
Loading another FastCast...
American Horror Story Recast

American Horror Story Recast

What if an actor played each individual role?
by Ryan Murphy
Do not add the same actor/actress from one role onto another. I don't want the same actor to be multiple roles (ex. Dylan O'Brien as the top choice for Kit Walker, Dandy, and Tate Langdon). Let's b...
See Story

Has this person been officially cast for this role? Click here.

Fan casting suggestion made by:

Join the Conversation

0 comments on Jay Baruchel as Jeff Pfister in American Horror Story Recast

Jay Baruchel is known for his roles in How to Train Your Dragon: The Hidden World, How to Train Your Dragon 2, and How to Train Your Dragon. He has been suggested by fans for 1,457 roles on myCast, including Waldo Butters in The Dresden Files. Similar actors include Bill Hader, Tom Holland, and Seth Rogen. Jay Baruchel was suggested to play Jeff Pfister in American Horror Story Recast by jazzyjayne23. Other actors sugggested to play this role include Andy Samberg, Michael Cera, and Seth Rogen. American Horror Story Recast has 135 roles, including Madison Montgomery, Zoe Benson, and The Countess.

More Fan Casting Suggestions for Jeff Pfister in American Horror Story Recast

Newest Stories

Ready to move onto another story? Here are a few more to browse. Assemble your dream cast!

See More