Fan Casting Carey Mulligan as Audrey Tindall/ Shelby Miller in American Horror Story Recast

jazzyjayne23 made this fan casting suggestion on July 15, 2020. What do you think? See below to cast your vote, or click here to see all fan casting suggestions for this role.

Carey Mulligan as Audrey Tindall/ Shelby Miller in American Horror Story Recast

Carey Mulligan

38 years old

Carey Hannah Mulligan (born May 28, 1985) is an English actress. She has received numerous accolades, including a British Academy Film Award and a Critics' Choice Movie Award, in addition to nomina...

See Profile

Loading another FastCast...

Audrey Tindall/ Shelby Miller in American Horror Story Recast

Fan Casting

Carey Mulligan

as

Audrey Tindall/ Shelby Miller (Roanoke)

in

American Horror Story Recast

Do you agree?

Vote Yes Vote No

American Horror Story Recast

American Horror Story Recast

What if an actor played each individual role?

by Ryan Murphy

Do not add the same actor/actress from one role onto another. I don't want the same actor to be multiple roles (ex. Dylan O'Brien as the top choice for Kit Walker, Dandy, and Tate Langdon). Let's b...

See Story

Has this person been officially cast for this role? Click here.

Fan casting suggestion made by:

Join the Conversation

0 comments on Carey Mulligan as Audrey Tindall/ Shelby Miller in American Horror Story Recast

Carey Mulligan is known for her roles in The Great Gatsby, Pride & Prejudice, and Drive. She has been suggested by fans for 1,572 roles on myCast, including Alice Longbottom in The Marauders. Similar actors include Amanda Seyfried, Emily Blunt, and Emma Stone. Carey Mulligan was suggested to play Audrey Tindall/ Shelby Miller in American Horror Story Recast by jazzyjayne23. Other actors sugggested to play this role include Imogen Poots, Claire Danes, and Sienna Miller. American Horror Story Recast has 135 roles, including Madison Montgomery, Zoe Benson, and The Countess.

Supporters (6)

Opposers (1)

trish_dw

More Fan Casting Suggestions for Audrey Tindall/ Shelby Miller in American Horror Story Recast

Dianna Agron

Dianna Agron

as

Audrey Tindall/ Shelby Miller (Roanoke)

in

American Horror Story Recast

9 Vote Yes

1 Vote No

Audrey Tindall/ Shelby Miller
Claire Foy

Claire Foy

as

Audrey Tindall/ Shelby Miller (Roanoke)

in

American Horror Story Recast

5 Vote Yes

2 Vote No

Audrey Tindall/ Shelby Miller
Imogen Poots

Imogen Poots

as

Audrey Tindall/ Shelby Miller (Roanoke)

in

American Horror Story Recast

4 Vote Yes

3 Vote No

Audrey Tindall/ Shelby Miller
Nell Hudson

Nell Hudson

as

Audrey Tindall/ Shelby Miller (Roanoke)

in

American Horror Story Recast

3 Vote Yes

2 Vote No

Audrey Tindall/ Shelby Miller
Sienna Miller

Sienna Miller

as

Audrey Tindall/ Shelby Miller (Roanoke)

in

American Horror Story Recast

2 Vote Yes

3 Vote No

Audrey Tindall/ Shelby Miller
Claire Danes

Claire Danes

as

Audrey Tindall/ Shelby Miller (Roanoke)

in

American Horror Story Recast

1 Vote Yes

4 Vote No

Audrey Tindall/ Shelby Miller

Newest Stories

Ready to move onto another story? Here are a few more to browse. Assemble your dream cast!

See More