Suggestions by @seryl

Mercedes McNab

as Susan "Sue" Storm in Fantastic Four

Score: 0

Tatum McCann

as Teen samantha in Click (2013)

Score: +1

Yasmin Paige

as Dana in True True Lie

Score: +1

Wario

as On & Off in Heroes Sorted by Heroes Wiki Categories

Score: +1

Ruby (Supernatural)

as Twist Villain in Sort by Tropes

Score: +2

Lucifer (DC Show)

as Daddy Issues in Sort by Tropes

Score: +2

Brittany Murphy

as Kat in 10 Things I Hate About You

Score: +1

Benedict Cumberbatch

as Andy Milton in Genderswap Supernatural

Score: +1

Ava Hughes

as Callie Garrison in Supernatural Reboot

Score: +1

Elle Graham

as Freya Mikaelson in The Originals

Score: 0

Lauren Kennedy

as Velma Dinkley in Scooby Doo: Ghost Patrol

Score: +1

ava joy

as Beth Kane in Batwoman

Score: +1

Andi Marie-Townsend

as Penelope Wilhern in Penelope

Score: +1

Brittany Murphy

as Harley Quinn in Harley Quinn DC Universe Animated Series (Live Action)

Score: -3

Alison Pill

as Marie Beck in Perfect Pie

Score: +1

Ryann Shane

as Amelia Earhart in Amelia (Amelia Earhart Bio)

Score: +1

Bailey Skodje

as Amelia Earhart in Amelia (Amelia Earhart Bio)

Score: +1

Roan Curtis

as Chloe Sullivan in Smallville

Score: -1

Tiara Santana

as Carmen Lowell in The Sisterhood of Traveling Pants

Score: +1

Alanna Dawn Ekkert

as Lena Kaligaris in The Sisterhood of Traveling Pants

Score: +1