Suggestions by @seryl

Macey Chipping

as Rose Hathaway in Vampire Academy

Score: +1

Ashley Yarman

as Nell Fenwick in Dudley Do Right

Score: +1

Elyssa D. Vito

as Dawn Summers in Buffy the Vampire Slayer (CW)

Score: 0

Candice Nicole

as Buffy Summers in Buffy the Vampire Slayer (CW)

Score: -1

Rebecca Codling

as Melissa Scully in The X-Files (Reboot)

Score: +1

Mimi Paley

as Buffy Summers in Buffy the Vampire Slayer (CW)

Score: -1

Melissa McCarthy

as Wanda in People We Meet On Vacation

Score: +2

Ashlyn Sanchez

as Renée Goursaud in Alias (2021-2026)

Score: 0

Ellen Muth

as Selena St. George in Dolores Claiborne

Score: 0

Hunter Ansley Wryn

as Piper Halliwell in Charmed

Score: +1

Olivia Devlin

as Alyssa Chang in Legacies

Score: +2

Olivia Nikkanen

as Alex Danvers in Supergirl (Arrowverse)

Score: +1

Hayley McCarthy

as Esther Mikaelson in The Originals

Score: +1

Lily Rose Mumford

as Josette Saltzman in The Originals

Score: +1

Kristin Erickson

as Dahlia in The Originals

Score: +1

Riley Voelkel

as Fiona Goode in American Horror Story Recast

Score: +1

Hayley McCarthy

as Esther in The Originals

Score: 0

Emma Lockhart

as Rachel Dawes in Batman Begins (2025)

Score: +1

Allison Gobuzzi

as Chanel Oberlin in Scream Queens (Reboot)

Score: +1

Ashlyn Jade Lopez

as Nadia Petrova in The Vampire Diaries

Score: +1