Suggestions by @rwhite18

Patrick Schwarzenegger

as Superman in DC: The New Frontier (2024)

Score: +2

Billy Crystal

as Frank Ginsburg in Little Miss Sunshine (1986)

Score: +2

Jake Gyllenhaal

as Les Grossman in Tropic Thunder (2018)

Score: +3

Olivia Cooke

as Jessica Jones in Spider-Man: Life Story Live Action

Score: +2

Oliver Jackson-Cohen

as Batman in Batman: Dark Victory (2029)

Score: +2

Teresa Wright

as Jessie Colin in Civil War (1944)

Score: +2

Katherine Hepburn

as Lee Smith in Civil War (1944)

Score: -1

Oliver Jackson-Cohen

as Bruce Wayne in Batman: The Long Halloween (2027)

Score: +1

Gary Oldman

as Winston Smith in 1984 (1994)

Score: +2

Christopher Walken

as John Doe in Se7en (1985)

Score: +2

Brad Dourif

as John Doe in Se7en (1985)

Score: +2

Kurt Russell

as David Mills in Se7en (1985)

Score: +2

Sylvester Stallone

as David Mills in Se7en (1985)

Score: +2

Ned Beatty

as William Somerset in Se7en (1985)

Score: +3

Al Pacino

as William Somerset in Se7en (1985)

Score: +2

Gene Hackman

as William Somerset in Se7en (1985)

Score: +2

Leonardo DiCaprio

as John H. Miller in Saving Private Ryan (2018)

Score: +2

Ryan Gosling

as Captain John Miller in Saving Private Ryan (2028)

Score: +2

Lucas Hedges

as Benjamin Braddock in The Graduate (2017)

Score: +2

Kerry Condon

as Anna Crowe in The Sixth Sense (2019)

Score: +2