Suggestions by @randomcaster

Sherlock Holmes

as Henry Cavill in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Score: +1

Sheldon J. Plankton

as Mr. Lawrence in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Score: +1

Skips

as Mark Hamill in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Score: +2

Wonder Woman (DCEU)

as Gal Gadot in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Score: +1

Kai (Kung Fu Panda 3)

as J.K. Simmons in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Score: +1

Omni-Man (Nolan Grayson)

as J.K. Simmons in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Score: +2

J. Jonah Jameson

as J.K. Simmons in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Score: +3

Superman (DCEU)

as Henry Cavill in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Score: +2

Ebenezer Scrooge

as Jim Carrey in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Score: +2

Uncle Fester Addams

as Fred Armisen in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Score: +2

Olaf

as Josh Gad in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Score: +1

Chief Bogo

as Idris Elba in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Score: +2

Knuckles the Echidna (Paramount)

as Idris Elba in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Score: +4

Bloodsport (DCEU)

as Idris Elba in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Score: +1

James P. Sullivan

as John Goodman in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Score: +5

Pacha

as John Goodman in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Score: +2

Ray the Firefly

as Jim Cummings in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Score: +1

Bart Simpson

as Nancy Cartwright in Best character each of these actors played (Voting version)

Score: +1