Suggestions by @pixelwolf

Kathryn Hunter

as Finger Reader Crone #2 in Elden Ring

Score: +3

Tallulah Haddon

as Rya in Elden Ring

Score: +2

Alex Lawther

as Boc the Seamster in Elden Ring

Score: +2

Vanessa Kirby

as Queen Marika the Eternal in Elden Ring

Score: +4

Mark Strong

as Starscourge Radahn in Elden Ring

Score: +4

Olivia Cooke

as Melina in Elden Ring

Score: -2

Jessica De Gouw

as Sorceress Sellen in Elden Ring

Score: +3

Mia Soteriou

as Finger Reader Crone in Elden Ring

Score: +1

Souad Faress

as Enia in Elden Ring

Score: +3

Dean Fagan

as Blackguard Big Boggart in Elden Ring

Score: +1

Huw Parmenter

as D, Hunter of the Dead in Elden Ring

Score: +1

Con O'Neill

as Mohg, Lord of Blood in Elden Ring

Score: +3

Mark Heap

as Godrick the Grafted in Elden Ring

Score: +6

Peter Capaldi

as Gowry in Elden Ring

Score: +4

Gabriel Byrne

as Gowry in Elden Ring

Score: +1

Saoirse Ronan

as Roderika in Elden Ring

Score: 0

Kaya Scodelario

as Millicent in Elden Ring

Score: +3

Jenna Coleman

as Melina in Elden Ring

Score: +6

Maisie Williams

as Ranni the Witch in Elden Ring

Score: -5

Faye Marsay

as Malenia, Blade of Miquella in Elden Ring

Score: +1