Suggestions by @pixelwolf

Shaun Dooley

as Bloody Finger Hunter Yura in Elden Ring

Score: -2

Pip Torrens

as White Mask Varre in Elden Ring

Score: +1

Hermione Corfield

as Fia in Elden Ring

Score: +3

Jamie Murray

as Sorceress Sellen in Elden Ring

Score: +3

Tilda Swinton

as Rennala, Queen of the Full Moon in Elden Ring

Score: +4

Richard Armitage

as Maliketh, the Black Blade in Elden Ring

Score: +3

Abbey Lee

as Latenna in Elden Ring

Score: +2

David O'Hara

as Sir Gideon Ofnir, the All-Knowing in Elden Ring

Score: +3

Richard Brake

as Godskin Apostle in Elden Ring

Score: +3

Vladimir "Furdo" Furdik

as Godskin Apostle in Elden Ring

Score: +3

Joseph Fiennes

as Rykard, Lord of Blasphemy in Elden Ring

Score: +3

Timothy Spall

as Godskin Noble in Elden Ring

Score: +3

Doug Jones

as Godskin Apostle in Elden Ring

Score: +4

Jodie Comer

as Fia in Elden Ring

Score: +5

Edward Bluemel

as Sorcerer Rogier in Elden Ring

Score: +1

Eva Green

as Lady Tanith in Elden Ring

Score: +4

Paul McEwan

as Gatekeeper Gostoc in Elden Ring

Score: +3

Mackenzie Crook

as Gatekeeper Gostoc in Elden Ring

Score: +3

Michael Sheen

as Preceptor Seluvis in Elden Ring

Score: +4

David Thewlis

as Godrick the Grafted in Elden Ring

Score: +2