Suggestions by @nathanbates

Paul Giamatti

as Luigi in Illumination's Super Mario Bros Duology (2003 - 2006)

Score: +4

Danny DeVito

as King Bowser in Illumination's Super Mario Bros Duology (2003 - 2006)

Score: +6

Joe Pantoliano

as Foreman Spike in Illumination's Super Mario Bros Duology (2003 - 2006)

Score: +6

Jason Alexander

as King Bowser in Illumination's Super Mario Bros Duology (2003 - 2006)

Score: +4

Spike Jonze

as Bowser Jr. in Illumination's Super Mario Bros Duology (2003 - 2006)

Score: +6

Alison Oliver

as Cheetah in Absolute Wonder Woman

Score: +2

Havana Rose Liu

as Barbara Minerva in Absolute Wonder Woman

Score: +2

Chi Lewis-Parry

as Ferdinand in Absolute Wonder Woman

Score: +2

Cillian Murphy

as Professor X in The Avengers

Score: +4

Cory Michael Smith

as Daniel Le Domas in Ready or Not

Score: +2

Naomi Watts

as Invisible Woman in The Avengers

Score: +6

Billy Crudup

as Mister Fantastic in The Avengers

Score: +8

William Jackson Harper

as Mister Fantastic in The Avengers

Score: +6

Josh Hartnett

as Mister Fantastic in The Avengers

Score: +6

Burt Lancaster

as William King Hale in Killers of the Flower Moon (1963)

Score: +2

Dakota Fanning

as Sally Owens in Practical Magic

Score: +4

Elle Fanning

as Gillian Owens in Practical Magic

Score: +4

Jeremy Strong

as Ian Hawke in Alvin and the Chipmunks (2017-2025)

Score: +6

Michelle Pfeiffer

as Rebecca Saint John in Eileen (1993)

Score: +2

Kathleen Turner

as Rebecca Saint John in Eileen (1993)

Score: +1