Suggestions by @ms_mosel
397 suggestions
Andrew Rannells
as Jim Bakker in Andrew Garfield Recast
Ethan Slater
as Nigel Bottom in Something Rotten!
Lizzy McAlpine
as Portia in Something Rotten!
Meghann Fahy
as Bea in Something Rotten!
Christian Borle
as Brother Jeremiah in Something Rotten!
Antonio Banderas
as Oliver Barrett III in Love Story
Colin Firth
as Oliver Barrett III in Love Story
John Bourgeois
as Brother Jeremiah in Something Rotten!
Emma Pittman
as Betty Schaeffer in Andrew Lloyd Webber's Sunset Boulevard (2020s decade)
Jeremy Pope
as Marcus Gaines in Fellow Travelers (remake)
Sean Kaufman
as Artie Green in Andrew Lloyd Webber's Sunset Boulevard (2020s decade)
Vanessa Kirby
as Lucy Fuller in Fellow Travelers (remake)
Layton Williams
as Frankie Hines in Fellow Travelers (remake)
Alisha Newton
as Kimberly Fuller in Fellow Travelers (remake)
Chris Perfetti
as Timothy Laughlin in Fellow Travelers (remake)
Jonathan Groff
as Hawkins Fuller in Fellow Travelers (remake)
Tommy Bowe
as Emcee in Cabaret
JJ Niemann
as Will Bloom in Big fish the musical
Nicole Scherzinger
as Kate in If/Then
Sofia Wylie
as Anne Wheeler in The Greatest Showman (Broadway Adaptation)