Suggestions by @ms_mosel
360 suggestions

Krysta Rodriguez
as Elizabeth Vaughn in If/Then

Erich Bergen
as Josh Burton in If/Then

Darren Criss
as Josh Burton in If/Then

Andy Mientus
as Lucas in If/Then

Nik Walker
as Stephen in If/Then

Katharine McPhee
as Elizabeth Vaughn in If/Then

Dempsey Bryk
as Young Miles in Ugly Love

Joseph Zada
as Young Ian in Ugly Love

Matthew Morrison
as Joe Josephson in Merrily We Roll Along

Austin Butler
as Joe Clay in Days Of Wine & Roses

Ann Harada
as Florence Menlove in Schmigadoon (Stage Adaptation)

David Hyde Pierce
as Mayor Menlove in Schmigadoon (Stage Adaptation)

Ryan McCartan
as Danny Bailey in Schmigadoon (Stage Adaptation)

Rachel Bay Jones
as Mildred Layton in Schmigadoon (Stage Adaptation)

Isabela Merced
as Emma Tate in Schmigadoon (Stage Adaptation)

McKenzie Kurtz
as Betsy McDonough in Schmigadoon (Stage Adaptation)

Sara Chase
as Melissa Gimble in Schmigadoon (Stage Adaptation)

Alex Brightman
as Josh Skinner in Schmigadoon (Stage Adaptation)

Stellan Skarsgård
as Mr. Arnesen in Days Of Wine & Roses

Daisy Edgar-Jones
as Kirsten Arnesen-Clay in Days Of Wine & Roses