Suggestions by @ml06us
1,438 suggestions
Crystal Reed
as Buffy Summers in If Teen Wolf Was . . . Buffy (1997-2003)
Shelley Hennig
as Suzanne " Sue " Snell in If Teen Wolf Was . . . Carrie (2013)
Crystal Reed
as Christine " Chris " Hargensen in If Teen Wolf Was . . . Carrie (2013)
Melissa Ponzio
as Miss Desjardins in If Teen Wolf Was . . . Carrie (2013)
Dylan O'Brien
as Tommy Ross in If Teen Wolf Was . . . Carrie (2013)
Eaddy Mays
as Eleanor Snell in If Teen Wolf Was . . . Carrie (2013)
Colton Haynes
as Billy Nolan in If Teen Wolf Was . . . Carrie (2013)
Susan Walters
as Margaret White in If Teen Wolf Was . . . Carrie (2013)
Holland Roden
as Carrie White in If Teen Wolf Was . . . Carrie (2013)
Kristine Sutherland
as Eleanor Snell in If Buffy Was . . . Carrie (2013)
David Boreanaz
as Billy Nolan in If Buffy Was . . . Carrie (2013)
Nicholas Brendon
as Tommy Ross in If Buffy Was . . . Carrie (2013)
Charisma Carpenter
as Christine " Chris " Hargensen in If Buffy Was . . . Carrie (2013)
Robia LaMorte
as Miss Desjardins in If Buffy Was . . . Carrie (2013)
Sarah Michelle Gellar
as Suzanne " Sue " Snell in If Buffy Was . . . Carrie (2013)
Alyson Hannigan
as Carrie White in If Buffy Was . . . Carrie (2013)
KJ Apa
as Tommy Ross in If Riverdale Was . . . Carrie (2013)
Cole Sprouse
as Billy Nolan in If Riverdale Was . . . Carrie (2013)
Mädchen Amick
as Eleanor Snell in If Riverdale Was . . . Carrie (2013)
Camila Mendes
as Christine " Chris " Hargensen in If Riverdale Was . . . Carrie (2013)