Suggestions by @ml06us
1,438 suggestions
Daniel Sharman
as Dawn Summers in If Teen Wolf Was . . . Buffy (1997-2003)
Tyler Hoechlin
as First Slayer in If Teen Wolf Was . . . Buffy (1997-2003)
Tyler Hoechlin
as Angel in If Teen Wolf Was . . . Buffy (1997-2003)
Crystal Reed
as Angel in If Teen Wolf Was . . . Buffy (1997-2003)
Holland Roden
as Cordelia Chase in If Teen Wolf Was . . . Buffy (1997-2003)
Tyler Hoechlin
as Rupert Giles in If Teen Wolf Was . . . Buffy (1997-2003)
Tyler Posey
as Buffy Summers in If Teen Wolf Was . . . Buffy (1997-2003)
Ryan Kelley
as Riley Finn in If Teen Wolf Was . . . Buffy (1997-2003)
Daniel Sharman
as Daniel " Oz " Osborne in If Teen Wolf Was . . . Buffy (1997-2003)
Dylan Sprayberry
as Dawn Summers in If Teen Wolf Was . . . Buffy (1997-2003)
Meagan Tandy
as First Slayer in If Teen Wolf Was . . . Buffy (1997-2003)
Ian Bohen
as Spike in If Teen Wolf Was . . . Buffy (1997-2003)
Shelley Hennig
as Anya Jenkins in If Teen Wolf Was . . . Buffy (1997-2003)
Matthew Del Negro
as Hank Summers in If Teen Wolf Was . . . Buffy (1997-2003)
Melissa Ponzio
as Joyce Summers in If Teen Wolf Was . . . Buffy (1997-2003)
Tyler Posey
as Angel in If Teen Wolf Was . . . Buffy (1997-2003)
Seth Gilliam
as Rupert Giles in If Teen Wolf Was . . . Buffy (1997-2003)
Colton Haynes
as Cordelia Chase in If Teen Wolf Was . . . Buffy (1997-2003)
Holland Roden
as Willow Rosenberg in If Teen Wolf Was . . . Buffy (1997-2003)
Dylan O'Brien
as Alexander Harris in If Teen Wolf Was . . . Buffy (1997-2003)