Suggestions by @ml06us
1,441 suggestions
Candice Accola
as Willow Rosenberg in If Vampire Diaries Was . . . Buffy
Nina Dobrev
as Buffy Summers in If Vampire Diaries Was . . . Buffy
Bethany Joy Lenz
as Josephine " Joey " Potter in If One Tree Hill Was . . . Dawson's Creek
Hilarie Burton
as Jennifer " Jen " Lindley in If One Tree Hill Was . . . Dawson's Creek
James Lafferty
as Pacey Witter in If One Tree Hill Was . . . Dawson's Creek
Chad Michael Murray
as Dawson Leary in If One Tree Hill Was . . . Dawson's Creek
David Schwimmer
as Principal Himbry in Stab : New Generation
Jordan Elsass
as Steven Orth in Stab : New Generation
Jordan Elsass
as Casey Becker in Stab : New Generation
Isabella Acres
as Casey Becker in Stab : New Generation
Isabel May
as Casey Becker in Stab : New Generation
Carson Rowland
as Stuart Macher in Stab : New Generation
Joe Keery
as Stuart Macher in Stab : New Generation
Jace Norman
as Stuart Macher in Stab : New Generation
Connor Jessup
as Stuart Macher in Stab : New Generation
Ty Simpkins
as Stuart Macher in Stab : New Generation
Elliot Fletcher
as Randy Meeks in Stab : New Generation
William Brent
as Randy Meeks in Stab : New Generation
Richard Ellis
as Randy Meeks in Stab : New Generation
Jake Austin Walker
as Randy Meeks in Stab : New Generation