Suggestions by @ml06us
1,438 suggestions
Matt Bomer
as Nathan Drake in Uncharted Saga (Adaptation)
Charisma Carpenter
as Abby Morgan in If Buffy Was . . . Dawson's Creek
Eric Balfour
as Pacey Witter in If Buffy Was . . . Dawson's Creek
Alyson Hannigan
as Josephine " Joey " Potter in If Buffy Was . . . Dawson's Creek
Sarah Michelle Gellar
as Jennifer " Jen " Lindley in If Buffy Was . . . Dawson's Creek
Nicholas Brendon
as Dawson Leary in If Buffy Was . . . Dawson's Creek
Tom Lenk
as Andrew Wells in If Charmed Met . . . Buffy
Adam Busch
as Warren Mears in If Charmed Met . . . Buffy
Danny Strong
as Jonathan Levinson in If Charmed Met . . . Buffy
Rose McGowan
as Paige Matthews in If Charmed Met . . . Buffy
Amber Benson
as Tara Maclay in If Charmed Met . . . Buffy
Elizabeth Anne Allen
as Amy Madison in If Charmed Met . . . Buffy
Holly Marie Combs
as Piper Halliwell in If Charmed Met . . . Buffy
Alyssa Milano
as Phoebe Halliwell in If Charmed Met . . . Buffy
Alyson Hannigan
as Willow Rosenberg in If Charmed Met . . . Buffy
Shannen Doherty
as Prue Halliwell in If Charmed Met . . . Buffy
Paul Wesley
as Angel/Angelus in If Vampire Diaries Was . . . Buffy
Ian Somerhalder
as Spike in If Vampire Diaries Was . . . Buffy
Candice Accola
as Willow Rosenberg in If Vampire Diaries Was . . . Buffy
Nina Dobrev
as Buffy Summers in If Vampire Diaries Was . . . Buffy