Suggestions by @jonrivera

Dar Salim

as Moses in The Passion of the Christ (Sequel)

Score: +1

Abigail Cowen

as Eve in The Passion of the Christ (Sequel)

Score: +1

Diego Boneta

as Adam in The Passion of the Christ (Sequel)

Score: +1

Moisés Iván Mora

as The Serpent in The Passion of the Christ (Sequel)

Score: +1

Bamshad Abedi-Amin

as Aurelius Augustinus "Augustine" in The Passion of the Christ (Sequel)

Score: +1

Ashraf Barhom

as Isaiah in The Passion of the Christ (Sequel)

Score: +1

Giovanni Capalbo

as Cassius Longinus in The Passion of the Christ (Sequel)

Score: +1

Marwan Kenzari

as Thomas the Apostle in The Passion of the Christ (Sequel)

Score: +1

Francesco De Vito

as Peter the Apostle in The Passion of the Christ (Sequel)

Score: +1

Monica Bellucci

as Mary Magdalene in The Passion of the Christ (Sequel)

Score: +2

Christo Jivkov

as John the Beloved in The Passion of the Christ (Sequel)

Score: +1

Jim Caviezel

as Jesus in The Passion of the Christ (Sequel)

Score: +1

Simon Kassianides

as Kleon in Paul of Tarsus

Score: +1

Paul Marc Davis

as Antonius Felix in Paul of Tarsus

Score: +1

Paras Patel

as Stephen the Martyr in Paul of Tarsus

Score: +2

Luca Lionello

as Elymas in Paul of Tarsus

Score: +1

Jack Huston

as Timothy of Ephesus in Paul of Tarsus

Score: +1

Darwin Shaw

as Ananias of Damascus in Paul of Tarsus

Score: +1

Nikolai Kinski

as Sergius Paulus in Paul of Tarsus

Score: +1

Tahar Rahim

as Aquila in Paul of Tarsus

Score: +1