Suggestions by @jonrivera

Jack Huston

as Simon ben Koseba in Legend of Destruction

Score: +1

Anthony Ramos

as Natan ben Yeshayahu in Legend of Destruction

Score: +1

Laëtitia Eïdo

as Bathsheba in King David

Score: +1

Alfred Molina

as Goliath in King David

Score: 0

Sacha Baron Cohen

as Samuel the Prophet in King David

Score: +1

Gal Gadot

as Michal in King David

Score: +1

James Marsden

as Jonathan in King David

Score: +1

Igal Naor

as King Saul in King David

Score: 0

Sebastian Croft

as Young David in King David

Score: +2

Rodrigo Santoro

as David in King David

Score: +1

Ashraf Barhom

as Zechariah of Jerusalem in Nativity

Score: +1

Laëtitia Eïdo

as Elizabeth of Jerusalem in Nativity

Score: +1

Eiza González

as Mary of Nazareth in Nativity

Score: +1

Tahar Rahim

as Joseph of Bethlehem in Nativity

Score: +1

Shaun Toub

as Mordecai in The Persian Queen

Score: +1

Tahar Rahim

as Artaxerxes in The Persian Queen

Score: +1

Melissa Barrera

as Esther in The Persian Queen

Score: +1

Jack Huston

as Michael the Archangel in The Passion of the Christ (Sequel)

Score: +1

Babou Ceesay

as Noah in The Passion of the Christ (Sequel)

Score: +1

Selva Rasalingam

as Elijah in The Passion of the Christ (Sequel)

Score: +1