Suggestions by @chefner

Cillian Murphy

as Billy Clanton in Belfast (2011)

Score: +1

Ian McShane

as Pop in Belfast (2011)

Score: +1

Liz Smith

as Granny in Belfast (2011)

Score: +2

Helen McCrory

as Ma in Belfast (2011)

Score: +1

Michael Fassbender

as Pa in Belfast (2011)

Score: +1

James Marsden

as Harry Osborn in Spider-Man (2002, alternate casting)

Score: +1

Laura Prepon

as Mary Jane Watson in Spider-Man (2002, alternate casting)

Score: +1

Bryan Cranston

as Norman Osborn in Spider-Man (2002, alternate casting)

Score: +1

Elijah Wood

as Peter Parker in Spider-Man (2002, alternate casting)

Score: +2

Vladimir Kulich

as Dredger in Sherlock Holmes (1999)

Score: +1

Danny Boyle

as Director in Sherlock Holmes (1999)

Score: +1

Edward Herrmann

as John Standish in Sherlock Holmes (1999)

Score: +1

Julia McKenzie

as Mrs. Hudson in Sherlock Holmes (1999)

Score: +1

Michael Wincott

as Lord Coward in Sherlock Holmes (1999)

Score: +1

Max von Sydow

as Sir Thomas in Sherlock Holmes (1999)

Score: +1

Melissa Gilbert

as Mary Morstan in Sherlock Holmes (1999)

Score: +1

Mark Williams

as Inspector Lestrade in Sherlock Holmes (1999)

Score: +1

Diane Lane

as Irene Adler in Sherlock Holmes (1999)

Score: +1

Gary Oldman

as Lord Henry Blackwood in Sherlock Holmes (1999)

Score: +2

Ralph Fiennes

as Dr. John Watson in Sherlock Holmes (1999)

Score: +2