Suggestions by @anapepper

Jessica Biel

as Karen Roe in one tree hill

Kate Hudson

as Deb Scott in one tree hill

Darren Mann

as Julian Baker in Back to Tree Hill

Kiernan Shipka

as Peyton Sawyer in Back to Tree Hill

Douglas Booth

as Lucas Scott in Back to Tree Hill

Emilia Clarke

as Quinn James in Back to Tree Hill

Michael B. Jordan

as Antwon Taylor in Back to Tree Hill

Tom Holland

as Marvin McFadden in Back to Tree Hill

Jennifer Connelly

as Karen Roe in Back to Tree Hill

Anna Torv

as Deborah Lee in Back to Tree Hill

Thandie Newton

as Victoria Davis in Back to Tree Hill

Zendaya

as Brooke Davis in Back to Tree Hill

Drew Van Acker

as Lucas Scott in Back to Tree Hill

Eric Dane

as Keith Scott in Back to Tree Hill

Greg Vaughan

as Dan Scott in Back to Tree Hill

Stephen Amell

as Cooper Lee in Back to Tree Hill

Jennifer Connelly

as Deborah Lee in Back to Tree Hill

Robbie Amell

as Nathan Scott in Back to Tree Hill

Eliza Taylor

as Peyton Sawyer in Back to Tree Hill

Lucy Boynton

as Haley James in Back to Tree Hill