Suggestions by @anapepper

Robbie Amell

as Lucas Scott in Back to Tree Hill

Score: +1

Emilia Clarke

as Quinn James in One Tree Hill Recast

Score: -1

Lucy Boynton

as Haley James in One Tree Hill Recast

Score: -2

Eric Dane

as Keith Scott in One Tree Hill Recast

Score: +4

Michael B. Jordan

as Antwon Taylor in One Tree Hill Recast

Score: +4

Greg Vaughan

as Dan Scott in One Tree Hill Recast

Score: +4

Jennifer Connelly

as Karen Roe in One Tree Hill Recast

Score: -1

Nick Robinson

as Jamie Scott in One Tree Hill Recast

Score: +3

Mackenzie Foy

as Lily Roe Scott in One Tree Hill Recast

Score: +4

Olivia Holt

as Millie Huxtable in One Tree Hill Recast

Score: +3

Robbie Amell

as Lucas Scott in One Tree Hill Recast

Score: -2

Matthew Daddario

as Nathan Scott in One Tree Hill Recast

Score: +4

Selena Gomez

as Quinn James in One Tree Hill Recast

Score: +2

Zendaya

as Brooke Davis in One Tree Hill Recast

Score: -4

Tom Holland

as Mouth McFadden in One Tree Hill Recast

Score: +4

Mckenna Grace

as Sawyer Brooke Scott in One Tree Hill Recast

Score: +2

Kiernan Shipka

as Peyton Sawyer in One Tree Hill Recast

Score: -3