Fan Casting Elisabeth Shue as Tiffany Madison in When a Stranger Calls (1986)

paristhefilmgirl made this fan casting suggestion on June 26, 2023. What do you think? See below to cast your vote, or click here to see all fan casting suggestions for this role.

Elisabeth Shue as Tiffany Madison in When a Stranger Calls (1986)

Elisabeth Shue

60 years old

Elisabeth Judson Shue (born October 6, 1963) is an American actress, best known for her starring roles in the films The Karate Kid (1984), Adventures in Babysitting (1987), Cocktail (1988), Back to...

See Profile

Loading another FastCast...

Tiffany Madison in When a Stranger Calls (1986)

Fan Casting

Elisabeth Shue

as

Tiffany Madison

in

When a Stranger Calls (1986)

Do you agree?

Vote Yes Vote No

When a Stranger Calls (1986)

When a Stranger Calls (1986)

What if When a Stranger Calls had been made 20 years earlier

by Universal Pictures

Jill Johnson, a young teenager, is asked to baby sit for a rich family in a massive 3 story house. The kids are sleeping, giving her no company until she gets a mysterious unknown call. When she fi...

See Story

Has this person been officially cast for this role? Click here.

Fan casting suggestion made by:

paristhefilmgirl

Join the Conversation

0 comments on Elisabeth Shue as Tiffany Madison in When a Stranger Calls (1986)

Elisabeth Shue is known for her roles in Back to the Future Part II, Back to the Future Part III, and The Karate Kid. She has been suggested by fans for 1,132 roles on myCast, including Debora in Baby Driver (1987). Similar actors include Jodie Foster, Helen Hunt, and Olivia d'Abo. Elisabeth Shue was suggested to play Tiffany Madison in When a Stranger Calls (1986) by paristhefilmgirl. Other actors sugggested to play this role include Helen Hunt, Robin Wright, and Kyra Sedgwick. When a Stranger Calls (1986) has 12 roles, including Jill Johnson, The Stranger, and Bobby.

Supporters (7)

Opposers (0)

Nobody opposes this suggestion yet.

More Fan Casting Suggestions for Tiffany Madison in When a Stranger Calls (1986)

Robin Wright

Robin Wright

as

Tiffany Madison

in

When a Stranger Calls (1986)

6 Vote Yes

1 Vote No

Tiffany Madison
Lisa Whelchel

Lisa Whelchel

as

Tiffany Madison

in

When a Stranger Calls (1986)

6 Vote Yes

1 Vote No

Tiffany Madison
Helen Hunt

Helen Hunt

as

Tiffany Madison

in

When a Stranger Calls (1986)

4 Vote Yes

1 Vote No

Tiffany Madison
Kyra Sedgwick

Kyra Sedgwick

as

Tiffany Madison

in

When a Stranger Calls (1986)

3 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

Tiffany Madison
Laura Dern

Laura Dern

as

Tiffany Madison

in

When a Stranger Calls (1986)

3 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

Tiffany Madison
Olivia d'Abo

Olivia d'Abo

as

Tiffany Madison

in

When a Stranger Calls (1986)

5 Vote Yes

3 Vote No

Tiffany Madison
Kim Richards

Kim Richards

as

Tiffany Madison

in

When a Stranger Calls (1986)

3 Vote Yes

1 Vote No

Tiffany Madison
Nicollette Sheridan

Nicollette Sheridan

as

Tiffany Madison

in

When a Stranger Calls (1986)

2 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

Tiffany Madison

Newest Stories

Ready to move onto another story? Here are a few more to browse. Assemble your dream cast!

See More