Fan Casting Marisa Tomei as Jill Johnson in When a Stranger Calls (1986)

chris83 made this fan casting suggestion on June 26, 2023. What do you think? See below to cast your vote, or click here to see all fan casting suggestions for this role.

Marisa Tomei as Jill Johnson in When a Stranger Calls (1986)

Marisa Tomei

59 years old

Marisa Tomei (born December 4, 1964) is an American actress. She has received various accolades, including an Academy Award and nominations for two further Academy Awards, a BAFTA Award, two Golden...

See Profile

Loading another FastCast...

Jill Johnson in When a Stranger Calls (1986)

Fan Casting

Marisa Tomei

as

Jill Johnson

in

When a Stranger Calls (1986)

Do you agree?

Vote Yes Vote No

When a Stranger Calls (1986)

When a Stranger Calls (1986)

What if When a Stranger Calls had been made 20 years earlier

by Universal Pictures

Jill Johnson, a young teenager, is asked to baby sit for a rich family in a massive 3 story house. The kids are sleeping, giving her no company until she gets a mysterious unknown call. When she fi...

See Story

Has this person been officially cast for this role? Click here.

Fan casting suggestion made by:

Join the Conversation

1 comment on Marisa Tomei as Jill Johnson in When a Stranger Calls (1986)

paristhefilmgirl @pakjirasan vote on this.

Like Reply

Marisa Tomei is known for her roles in Captain America: Civil War, The Wrestler, and Spider-Man: Homecoming. She has been suggested by fans for 3,009 roles on myCast, including Marvel Cinematic Universe in Hottest Actress by Franchise. Similar actors include Sandra Bullock, Winona Ryder, and Scarlett Johansson. Marisa Tomei was suggested to play Jill Johnson in When a Stranger Calls (1986) by chris83. Other actors sugggested to play this role include Mariska Hargitay, Sandra Bullock, and Laura San Giacomo. When a Stranger Calls (1986) has 12 roles, including Tiffany Madison, The Stranger, and Bobby.

Supporters (4)

Opposers (2)

More Fan Casting Suggestions for Jill Johnson in When a Stranger Calls (1986)

Lori Loughlin

Lori Loughlin

as

Jill Johnson

in

When a Stranger Calls (1986)

8 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

Jill Johnson
Mia Sara

Mia Sara

as

Jill Johnson

in

When a Stranger Calls (1986)

5 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

Jill Johnson
Lisa Rinna

Lisa Rinna

as

Jill Johnson

in

When a Stranger Calls (1986)

5 Vote Yes

1 Vote No

Jill Johnson
Jill Schoelen

Jill Schoelen

as

Jill Johnson

in

When a Stranger Calls (1986)

4 Vote Yes

1 Vote No

Jill Johnson
Jennifer Rubin

Jennifer Rubin

as

Jill Johnson

in

When a Stranger Calls (1986)

4 Vote Yes

1 Vote No

Jill Johnson
Sandra Bullock

Sandra Bullock

as

Jill Johnson

in

When a Stranger Calls (1986)

4 Vote Yes

1 Vote No

Jill Johnson
Laura San Giacomo

Laura San Giacomo

as

Jill Johnson

in

When a Stranger Calls (1986)

3 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

Jill Johnson
Courteney Cox

Courteney Cox

as

Jill Johnson

in

When a Stranger Calls (1986)

3 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

Jill Johnson

Newest Stories

Ready to move onto another story? Here are a few more to browse. Assemble your dream cast!

See More