Fan Casting Evan Peters as Jay Gatsby in The Great Gatsby (2023)

ramimalekeyes made this fan casting suggestion on May 7, 2024. What do you think? See below to cast your vote, or click here to see all fan casting suggestions for this role.

Evan Peters as Jay Gatsby in The Great Gatsby (2023)

Evan Peters

37 years old

Evan Thomas Peters is an American actor. He is best known for his multiple roles on the FX anthology series American Horror Story, as Stan Bowes in the first season of the FX ballroom drama series ...

See Profile

Loading another FastCast...

Jay Gatsby in The Great Gatsby (2023)

Fan Casting

Evan Peters

as

Jay Gatsby

in

The Great Gatsby (2023)

Do you agree?

Vote Yes Vote No

The Great Gatsby (2023)

The Great Gatsby (2023)

Nick Carraway recounts his interactions with millionaire Jay Gatsby amid the riotous parties of the Jazz Age on Long Island in New York.

See Story

Fan casting suggestion made by:

Join the Conversation

0 comments on Evan Peters as Jay Gatsby in The Great Gatsby (2023)

Evan Peters is known for his roles in X-Men: Apocalypse, X-Men: Days of Future Past, and Deadpool 2. He has been suggested by fans for 5,362 roles on myCast, including Best in Best & Worst Comic Book Castings. Similar actors include Robert Pattinson, Bill Skarsgård, and Aaron Taylor-Johnson. Evan Peters was suggested to play Jay Gatsby in The Great Gatsby (2023) by ramimalekeyes. Other actors sugggested to play this role include Glen Powell, Austin Butler, and Chris Evans. The Great Gatsby (2023) has 7 roles, including Nick Carraway, Daisy Buchanan, and Tom Buchanan.

Supporters (2)

Opposers (4)

More Fan Casting Suggestions for Jay Gatsby in The Great Gatsby (2023)

Robert Pattinson

Robert Pattinson

as

Jay Gatsby

in

The Great Gatsby (2023)

17 Vote Yes

1 Vote No

The Great Gatsby (2023)
Chris Evans

Chris Evans

as

Jay Gatsby

in

The Great Gatsby (2023)

12 Vote Yes

2 Vote No

The Great Gatsby (2023)
Jonathan Groff

Jonathan Groff

as

Jay Gatsby

in

The Great Gatsby (2023)

11 Vote Yes

1 Vote No

The Great Gatsby (2023)
Austin Butler

Austin Butler

as

Jay Gatsby

in

The Great Gatsby (2023)

11 Vote Yes

1 Vote No

The Great Gatsby (2023)
Glen Powell

Glen Powell

as

Jay Gatsby

in

The Great Gatsby (2023)

7 Vote Yes

1 Vote No

The Great Gatsby (2023)
Chris Pine

Chris Pine

as

Jay Gatsby

in

The Great Gatsby (2023)

6 Vote Yes

2 Vote No

The Great Gatsby (2023)
Ryan Gosling

Ryan Gosling

as

Jay Gatsby

in

The Great Gatsby (2023)

4 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

The Great Gatsby (2023)
Dan Stevens

Dan Stevens

as

Jay Gatsby

in

The Great Gatsby (2023)

3 Vote Yes

0 Vote No

The Great Gatsby (2023)

Newest Stories

Ready to move onto another story? Here are a few more to browse. Assemble your dream cast!

See More