Suggestions by @yourstruly
97 suggestions
Angus Sampson
as Achenar in Myst Series

Margaret Qualley
as Erotica Ann 333 in Starstruck (Comic Series, 1982-2017)

Ilona Maher
as Brucilla The Muscle in Starstruck (Comic Series, 1982-2017)

Margaret Qualley
as Sundry Sidney in A Starstruck Odyssey

Maya Hawke
as Margaret Encino in A Starstruck Odyssey
Andrew Koji
as Norman “Skip” Takamori in A Starstruck Odyssey

Adrian Brody
as Detective Hunch Curio in Dimension 20: Mentopolis

Woody Harrelson
as The Fix in Dimension 20: Mentopolis
Samira Wiley
as Wynn in Lifeline Series (Game)

Vico Ortiz
as Taylor / T2 in Lifeline Series (Game)

Vico Ortiz
as Princeps Zortch in A Starstruck Odyssey

Nicholas Hoult
as Aitrus in Myst Series

Jamie Campbell Bower
as Veovis in Myst Series

Javier Bardem
as Father Garcia in FAItH: The Unholy Trinity

Sigourney Weaver
as Mama in The Adventure Zone: Amnesty

Winona Ryder
as Mama in The Adventure Zone: Amnesty

Phoebe Waller-Bridge
as Nikola Orsinov in The Magnus Archives (A Horror Anthology Podcast)
Julia Jones
as Catherine/Katran in Myst Series

Christopher Walken
as Gehn in Myst Series

Zoë Kravitz
as Lucienne Rex in A Starstruck Odyssey