Suggestions by @xvxnxaaa

Sydney Sweeney

as MJ in The Deal

Gregg Sulkin

as Justin Kohl in The Deal

Freddie Stroma

as Cooper Clay in One of Us Is Lying

Willa Fitzgerald

as Aerin in The Amateurs

Alexander Arnold

as Nate Macauley in One of Us Is Lying

Sasha Pieterse

as Helena in The Amateurs

Zendaya

as Seneca in The Amateurs

Brant Daugherty

as Pike Lawson in Birthday Girl

Chad Michael Murray

as Maxon in The Selection Series

Rachel Keller

as Cam in Birthday Girl

Cody Christian

as Cole Lawson in Birthday Girl

Ben Affleck

as Pike Lawson in Birthday Girl

Mia Healey

as Jordan Hadley in Birthday Girl

Rachel Keller

as Cam in Birthday girl (movie)

Cody Christian

as Cole lawson in Birthday girl (movie)

Mia Healey

as Jordan Hadley in Birthday girl (movie)

Denise Richards

as Brooke in Paper Princess

Henry Cavill

as Callum Royal in Paper Princess

Tyler Hoechlin

as Gideon Royal in Paper Princess

Manu Ríos

as Easton Royal in Paper Princess