Suggestions by @wyattboi
342 suggestions
Charlie Day
as Luigi in Super Mario Bros 2: electric boogaloo
Score: +1
Timothée Chalamet
as Dorian Gray in The Haunted Mansion
Score: +1
Willem Dafoe
as Henry Ravenswood in The Haunted Mansion
Score: +2
Will Arnett
as The Ghost Host in The Haunted Mansion
Score: +2
David Howard Thornton
as Joker in The Perfect Batman Movie Cast
Score: +2
David Howard Thornton
as Joker in Batman
Score: +4
Jensen Ackles
as Batman in Who should play Batman in the DCU
Score: +2
Willem Dafoe
as The Ghost Host in The Haunted Mansion
Score: -2
Willem Dafoe
as The Ghost Host in Tim Burton's The Haunted Mansion (1999) (Phantom Manor Being UK & French Title)
Score: 0
Chris Pratt
as Mario in Super Mario Bros 2: electric boogaloo
Score: +1
William Afton
as Purple in Fictional Characters by Colours of the Rainbow
Score: +5
Willem Dafoe
as William Afton in Fredbear's family diner
Score: +1
Gary Oldman
as William Afton in Fredbear's family diner
Score: +1
William Afton
as Jim Carrey in Characters you want famous actors to voice act.
Score: +5
Elizabeth Afton
as Millie Bobby Brown in Which character would like to see each Actor and Actresses play in Live Action
Score: +1
William Afton
as Jim Carrey in Which character would like to see each Actor and Actresses play in Live Action
Score: +2
William Afton
as Willem Dafoe in Which character would like to see each Actor and Actresses play in Live Action
Score: +1
William Afton
as Five Nights at Freddy's in All Fictional Characters Sorted by Media
Score: +2
William Afton
as Would Hurt a Child in Sort by Tropes
Score: +6
William Afton
as Five Nights at Freddy's in Villains
Score: +3