Suggestions by @wolfred17
406 suggestions
Scott Bakula
as Green Lantern in Justice Society of America (2009)
Score: +1
Simon Pegg
as The Mad Hatter in The Batman (Alternative Cast)
Score: +1
Daniel Kaluuya
as Firefly in The Batman (Alternative Cast)
Score: +1
Matt Smith
as Riddler in The Batman (Alternative Cast)
Score: +1
Olivia Wilde
as Catwoman in The Batman (Alternative Cast)
Score: +1
Andy Serkis
as Alfred Pennyworth in The Batman (Alternative Cast)
Score: +2
Michael Madsen
as Harvey Bullock in The Batman (Alternative Cast)
Score: +1
Katherine McNamara
as Batgirl in The Batman (Alternative Cast)
Score: +1
Peter Cullen
as Best IDW in The Comic Book Casting Awards(story removed)
Score: 0
Charitra Chandan
as SCP-273 in SCP Area 96 Movie (2030)
Score: +2
Nicholas Alexander Chavez
as Security Department Soldier #7 in SCP Area 96 Movie (2030)
Score: +1
Jeffrey Wright
as Bad Casting, Good Writing in The Comic Book Casting Awards(story removed)
Score: +2
John Cena
as Good Casting, Good Writing in The Comic Book Casting Awards(story removed)
Score: +5
Robert Pattinson
as Good Casting, Good Writing in The Comic Book Casting Awards(story removed)
Score: +4
Denzel Washington
as Two Face in Matt Reeves’s Two Face
Score: +1
Colin Farrell
as Best DC in The Comic Book Casting Awards(story removed)
Score: +6
The Batman Who Laughs
as Worst Batman Arc in The Comic Book Casting Awards(story removed)
Score: +1
Superior Spider-Man
as Best Spider-Man Redemption Arc in The Comic Book Casting Awards(story removed)
Score: +2
Channing Tatum
as Worst Superman in The Comic Book Casting Awards(story removed)
Score: 0
Tom Welling
as Best Superman in The Comic Book Casting Awards(story removed)
Score: +6