Suggestions by @wiltedsunflower

Milo Manheim

as Frederick J. Fitzwilliam in My Roommate is a Vampire

Score: +2

Eiza González

as Isa in The Spanish Love Deception

Score: +37

Gemma Arterton

as Odette Ferrara in Love and Gelato

Score: +5

Brooklynn Prince

as Gabriella Ferrara in Love and Gelato

Score: +2

Lexi Rabe

as Gabriella Ferrara in Love and Gelato

Score: +8

Lexi Rabe

as Odette Ferrara in Love and Gelato

Score: +1

Isabella Pappas

as Elena in Love and Gelato

Score: -7

Poorna Jagannathan

as Sonia in Love and Gelato

Score: -1

Eden McCoy

as Mimi in Love and Gelato

Score: -10

Kylie Rogers

as Mimi in Love and Gelato

Score: -3

Emily Skinner

as Mimi in Love and Gelato

Score: +6

Lizzy Greene

as Mimi in Love and Gelato

Score: +4

Gaia Girace

as Carolina "Lina" Emerson in Love and Gelato

Score: -23

Kate Hudson

as Hadley Emerson in Love and Gelato

Score: -8

Kirsten Dunst

as Hadley Emerson in Love and Gelato

Score: -9

Louis Partridge

as Thomas Heath in Love and Gelato

Score: +23

Matthew McConaughey

as Howard Mercer in Love and Gelato

Score: +1

Sterling K. Brown

as James Grant in The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo

Score: +13