Suggestions by @williamvisnosky
60 suggestions

Michael Clarke Duncan
as Apocalypse in X-Men (1996)

Ethan Suplee
as The Blob in X-Men (1996)

Paul Rudd
as Iceman in X-Men (1996)

John Goodman
as Beast in X-Men (1996)

Seth Green
as Banshee in X-Men (1996)

Leonardo DiCaprio
as Angel in X-Men (1996)

Ving Rhames
as Bishop in X-Men (1996)

Angela Bassett
as Storm in X-Men (1996)

Neve Campbell
as Shadowcat in X-Men (1996)

Denise Richards
as Jean Grey in X-Men (1996)

Helena Bonham Carter
as Rogue in X-Men (1996)

Johnny Depp
as Gambit in X-Men (1996)

Kurt Russell
as Cable in X-Men (1996)

Neil Patrick Harris
as Nightcrawler in X-Men (1996)

Arnold Schwarzenegger
as Colossus in X-Men (1996)

Jim Carrey
as Morph in X-Men (1996)

Patrick Stewart
as Professor X in X-Men (1996)

Matt Damon
as Cyclops in X-Men (1996)

Mel Gibson
as Wolverine in X-Men (1996)

James Cameron
as Director in X-Men (1996)