Suggestions by @will_free

Zachary Quinto

as Celebrimbor in Middle-Earth: Shadow of Mordor

Score: +1

Sebastian Stan

as Talion in Middle-Earth: Shadow of Mordor

Score: +1

Joshua Bassett

as 2020s in Spider-Man actors in different decades

Score: +1

Logan Lerman

as 2010s in Spider-Man actors in different decades

Score: +2

Joseph Gordon-Levitt

as 2000s in Spider-Man actors in different decades

Score: +2

Chris O'Donnell

as 1990s in Spider-Man actors in different decades

Score: +1

Matthew Broderick

as 1980s in Spider-Man actors in different decades

Score: +1

Mark Hamill

as 1970s in Spider-Man actors in different decades

Score: +1

Gustaf Skarsgård

as The Phantom of the Opera in The Universal Monsters

Score: +1

Mark Steger

as The Gill-Man in The Universal Monsters

Score: +1

James McAvoy

as Dr. Henry Jekyll in The Universal Monsters

Score: +1

Kaya Scodelario

as The Bride of Frankenstein in The Universal Monsters

Score: +1

Matt Smith

as The Invisible Man in The Universal Monsters

Score: +1

Mido Hamada

as The Mummy in The Universal Monsters

Score: +1

Jamie Dornan

as The Wolf Man in The Universal Monsters

Score: +1

Kevin Durand

as Frankenstein's Monster in The Universal Monsters

Score: +1

Mads Mikkelsen

as Count Dracula in The Universal Monsters

Score: +1

Jemaine Clement

as King K. Rool in Mario Franchise

Score: +1

Alex Hirsch

as Lemmy Koopa in Mario Franchise

Score: +1

Eric André

as Iggy Koopa in Mario Franchise

Score: +1