Suggestions by @whitewolf

Joely Richardson

as Jobe Watson in Essendon 34

Score: -1

Sam Neill

as Stephen Dank in Essendon 34

Score: +1

Matthew McConaughey

as James Hird in Essendon 34

Score: -1

Dan Fogler

as Mad Hatter in James Gunn DCEU Villains

Score: +1

Paul Wight

as Killer Croc in James Gunn DCEU Villains

Score: +1

Mike Mizanin

as Johnny Cage in Mortal kombat 2

Score: +2

Jason Schwartzman

as Jervis Tech in The Batman| Affleck's Batman

Score: +1

Josh Brolin

as Harvey Dent in The Batman| Affleck's Batman

Score: +2

David Tennant

as Edward Nygma in The Batman| Affleck's Batman

Score: +1

tommy tiny lister

as FryGuy in Super Mario Bros. 2 The Movie

Score: +1

Ryan Destiny

as FryGuy in Super Mario Bros. 2 The Movie

Score: -1

Dean Jones

as Dr Mouser in Super Mario Bros. 2 The Movie

Score: -1

Kevin Nash

as Clawgrip in Super Mario Bros. 2 The Movie

Score: +1

Debi Mazar

as Lady Triclyde in Super Mario Bros. 2 The Movie

Score: +1