Suggestions by @wavelength

Ethan Suplee

as Murray in Sly Cooper Movie Trilogy

+1-5Score: -4

Johnny Galecki

as Bentley in Sly Cooper Movie Trilogy

+5-5Score: 0

Johnny Knoxville

as Bentley in Sly Cooper Movie Trilogy

+3-7Score: -4

Ryan Reynolds

as Sly Cooper in Sly Cooper Movie Trilogy

+13-4Score: +9

Sofía Vergara

as Inspector Carmelita Montoya Fox in Sly Cooper Movie Trilogy

+3-2Score: +1