Suggestions by @watchmen

Armie Hammer

as Captain Metropolis in Before Watchmen: Minutemen

Matt Bomer

as Ozymandias in Before Watchmen: Minutemen

Michael Fassbender

as Dr. Manhattan in Before Watchmen: Minutemen

Michael Giacchino

as Composer in Before Watchmen: Minutemen

Brad Bird

as Writer in Before Watchmen: Minutemen

Brad Bird

as Director in Before Watchmen: Minutemen

Forrest Wheeler

as Scout in Before Watchmen: Minutemen

Lewis Tan

as Bluecoat in Before Watchmen: Minutemen

John Carroll Lynch

as J. Edgar Hoover in Before Watchmen: Minutemen

Jake Gyllenhaal

as Nite Owl II in Before Watchmen: Minutemen

Daniel Brühl

as Hooded Justice in Before Watchmen: Minutemen

Sebastian Stan

as Nite Owl in Before Watchmen: Minutemen

Mark Hamill

as Hollis Mason (old) in Before Watchmen: Minutemen

Dave Gibbons

as Producer in Before Watchmen: Minutemen