Suggestions by @vernorexia

Ika Musume

as Squids in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Princess Lumina

as Seahorses in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Scorpia

as Scorpion in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Chelsea Roberts

as Ponies in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Maud Pie

as Rocks in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Percy Jackson

as Pegasuses in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Lia Venegas

as Pegasuses in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Louise Belcher

as Chinchillas in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Phoenix Wright

as Phoenix in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Princess Celestia

as Phoenix in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Fluttershy

as Deer in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Sweet Grapes

as Butterfly in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Frankie Stein (G3)

as Robots in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Simon Blackquill

as Hawk in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Detective Lynne (Ghost Trick)

as Dogs in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Detective Jowd (Ghost Trick)

as Cats in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Yomiel (Ghost Trick)

as Cats in Sorting Fictional Characters by Which Pet They'd Have

Twilight Sparkle

as Homoromantic in LGBT Headcanons for Fictional Characters

Klavier Gavin

as Pansexual in LGBT Headcanons for Fictional Characters

Rainbow Dash

as Lesbian in LGBT Headcanons for Fictional Characters