Suggestions by @user_353599

Charli xcx

as Sauce in Chocolate

Kyla Kowalewski

as Chocolate Jr. in Chocolate

John DiMaggio

as Reddish Tomato in Chocolate

Maulik Pancholy

as Donut in Chocolate

Daniella Monet

as Apple in Chocolate

Jeremy Shada

as Coconut in Chocolate

Pia Mia

as Orange in Chocolate

Poppy Lee Friar

as Y E in Chocolate

Rebecca Grimes

as Cand Can in Chocolate

Dakota Fanning

as Ice Cream in Chocolate

Tom Kenny

as Peppermint in Chocolate

Tara Strong

as Cupcake in Chocolate

John Omohundro

as Vanilla in Chocolate

Adam Levine

as Strawberry in Chocolate

Grey DeLisle

as Grape in Chocolate

Jessica DiCicco

as Banana in Chocolate

Allana Williams

as Marshmallow in Chocolate

Nicki Minaj

as Pinkish Gum in Chocolate

Ben Schwartz

as Lime in Chocolate

Kristen Schaal

as Chocolate in Chocolate