Suggestions by @user_352657

Deva Cassel

as Sara Beatreaux in Scarred

Score: +2

Eugenio Franceschini

as Cade in Crossed

Score: -1

Chad Michael Murray

as Parker in Crossed

Score: +1

Alexandra Daddario

as Amaya in Crossed

Score: -2

Adriana Lima

as Amaya in Crossed

Score: 0

Isabelle Drummond

as Sara Beatreaux in Scarred

Score: +2

Manon Bannerman

as Yasmin in Twisted (a never after series)

Score: +2

Dove Cameron

as Dorothy in Wretched

Score: +1

Olivia Rodrigo

as Sara Beatreaux in Scarred

Score: -3

Natalie Portman

as Sara Beatreaux in Scarred

Score: -2

Phoebe Dynevor

as Wendy in Hooked

Score: +2

Kennedy Walsh

as Evelina Westerly in Wretched

Score: +1

Olivia Rodrigo

as Evelina Westerly in Wretched

Score: +3