Suggestions by @user_33608

Sofia Wylie

as Sophie in Mamma Mia! Remake

Score: -1

Kerry Washington

as Donna in Mamma Mia! Remake

Score: -1

Jermaine Clement

as Bill Anderson in Mamma Mia Remake

Score: +1

Sadie Sink

as Lisa in Mamma Mia Remake

Score: +1

Maitreyi Ramakrishnan

as Ali in Mamma Mia Remake

Score: +1

Colin Farrell

as Sam Carmichael in Mamma Mia Remake

Score: +1

Sofía Vergara

as Tanya in Mamma Mia Remake

Score: +1

Jordan Fisher

as Pepper in Mamma Mia Remake

Score: +1

Asher Angel

as Sky in Mamma Mia Remake

Score: +1

Gavin Creel

as Harry Bright in Mamma Mia Remake

Score: +1

Tara Lynne O'Neill

as Rosie in Mamma Mia Remake

Score: +1

Sofia Wylie

as Sophie Sheridan in Mamma Mia Remake

Score: +3

Kerry Washington

as Donna Sheridan in Mamma Mia Remake

Score: +2

Nani Pelekai

as Disney Princesses (Full) in Disney Sorting

Score: +7

Michael Greyeyes

as Brainiac in The Perfect Superman Movie

Score: +2

Sam Riley

as Brainiac in Superman

Score: 0

Michael Greyeyes

as Brainiac in Superman

Score: 0

Michelle Dockery

as Narcissa Malfoy in The PERFECT Harry Potter Reboot

Score: +1

Rosamund Pike

as Narcissa Malfoy in The PERFECT Harry Potter Reboot

Score: +2

Jodie Whittaker

as Narcissa Malfoy in The PERFECT Harry Potter Reboot

Score: +3