Suggestions by @user_32269

Andrew Koji

as Tim Wright in Marble Hornets

Score: +1

Stephanie Beatriz

as Rosemary Walten in The Walten Files

Score: -1

Kate Beckinsale

as Rosemary Walten in The Walten Files

Score: -3

Rose Byrne

as Rosemary Walten in The Walten Files

Score: -1

Tina Fey

as Rosemary Walten in The Walten Files

Score: -3

Neve Campbell

as Rosemary Walten in The Walten Files

Score: +1

Carla Gugino

as Rosemary Walten in The Walten Files

Score: +1

Joan Cusack

as Rosemary Walten in The Walten Files

Score: -1

Julia Roberts

as Rosemary Walten in The Walten Files

Score: -1

Linda Cardellini

as Rosemary Walten in The Walten Files

Score: -1

Ben Hardy

as Brian Stells in The Walten Files

Score: 0

Lucas Till

as Brian Stells in The Walten Files

Score: +1

Toby Regbo

as Brian Stells in The Walten Files

Score: -1

Dane DeHaan

as Brian Stells in The Walten Files

Score: +1

Violet Brinson

as Jenny Letterson in The Walten Files

Score: -3

Piper Mackenzie Harris

as Jenny Letterson in The Walten Files

Score: -1

Elaine Haro

as Jenny Letterson in The Walten Files

Score: -3

Eloise Rakic-Platt

as Jenny Letterson in The Walten Files

Score: -1

Daria Milky

as Jenny Letterson in The Walten Files

Score: -3

Sarah Louise Madison

as Jenny Letterson in The Walten Files

Score: -3