Suggestions by @user_29326

Jared Leto

as Ozymandias in Watchmen

Score: +1

Damian Lewis

as Rorschach in Watchmen

Score: -2

John Krasinski

as Nite Owl 2 in Watchmen

Score: +3

Ewan McGregor

as Dr. Manhattan in Watchmen

Score: 0

Wilson Bethel

as Moloch in Minutemen

Score: +1

Jason Schwartzman

as Laurence Schexnayder in Minutemen

Score: +1

Liam Hemsworth

as Dollar Bill in Minutemen

Score: +1

Nick Robinson

as Dollar Bill in Minutemen

Score: +1

Brenton Thwaites

as Mothman in Minutemen

Score: +1

Elizabeth Debicki

as Silhouette in Minutemen

Score: -1

Scott Eastwood

as Night Owl in Minutemen

Score: 0

Jake McDorman

as Captain Metropolis in Minutemen

Score: +2

Margot Robbie

as Silk Spectre in Minutemen

Score: +1

Cameron Monaghan

as Comedian in Minutemen

Score: +1

Lucas Till

as Night Owl in Minutemen

Score: -1

Jovan Adepo

as Hooded Justice in Minutemen

Score: 0