Suggestions by @user_28893

Nina Dobrev

as Madison McCarthy in Glee (2004-2010)

Josh Peck

as Dave Karofsky in Glee (2004-2010)

Emma Roberts

as Becky Jackson in Glee (2004-2010)

Keke Palmer

as Jane Hayward in Glee (2004-2010)

Taylor Lautner

as Joe Hart in Glee (2004-2010)

Jessica Simpson

as Cassandra July in Glee (2004-2010)

Drake Bell

as Rory Flanagan in Glee (2004-2010)

Blake Lively

as Kitty Wilde in Glee (2004-2010)

Romeo

as Jake Puckerman in Glee (2004-2010)

Rihanna

as Unique Adams in Glee (2004-2010)

Matthew Perry

as Burt Hummel in Glee (2004-2010)

Willa Ford

as Terri Schuester in Glee (2004-2010)

Cody Linley

as Sam Evans in Glee (2004-2010)

Anna Maria Perez De Taglé

as Tina Cohen-Chang in Glee (2004-2010)

Meaghan Martin

as Quinn Fabray in Glee (2004-2010)

Shay Mitchell

as Santana Lopez in Glee (2004-2010)

Megan Park

as Quinn Fabray in Glee (2004-2010)

Michael Copon

as Finn Hudson in Glee (2004-2010)

Claire Holt

as Brittany Pierce in Glee (2004-2010)

Selena Gomez

as Rachel Berry in Glee (2004-2010)