Suggestions by @user_214973

Michelle Monaghan

as Shelly Webster in The Crow (2004)

Rose McGowan

as Shelly Webster in The Crow

Christian Slater

as The Crow in The Crow

Christian Slater

as Eric Draven in The Crow 1994 Alternative Cast

Sigourney Weaver

as Nancy Loomis/Debby Salt in Scream 1-6 2003-2016

Kyle Gallner

as Charlie Walker in Scream 1-6 2003-2016

Rooney Mara

as Jill Roberts in Scream 1-6 2003-2016

Christian Slater

as Dexter Morgan in Dexter (1980s)

Dominic Sessa

as Brian Moser in Dexter: Original Sin

Daisy Edgar-Jones

as Debra Morgan in Dexter: Original Sin

Christian Slater

as Harry Morgan in Dexter: Original Sin

Dacre Montgomery

as Dexter Morgan in Dexter: Original Sin

Jake Sim

as Ram Sweeney in Heathers

Mason Dye

as Kurt Kelly in Heathers

Olivia Cooke

as Veronica Sawyer in Heathers

Olivia Cooke

as Veronica Sawyer in Heathers

Emma Stone

as Gale Weathers in Scream 1-6 recast

Young Leonardo Dicaprio

as Stu Macher in The Scream Original Trilogy (1996-2000) Alternate Fancast

Christian Bale

as Roman Bridger in The Scream Original Trilogy (1996-2000) Alternate Fancast

Owen Teague

as Jason Dean in Heathers the Musical: The Movie