Suggestions by @urlocalgothchloe
12 suggestions
Charlie Heaton
as Liu Woods in Creepypastas Characters.
+11-1Score: +10
Mackenzie Foy
as Lazari Natalie Swann in Creepypastas Characters.
+2-1Score: +1
Tiffany Espensen
as Lulu in Creepypastas Characters.
+2-1Score: +1
Maya Hawke
as Clockwork in Creepypastas Characters.
+5-1Score: +4
Wi Ha-jun
as Bloody Painter in Creepypastas Characters.
+4-1Score: +3
Booboo Stewart
as The Puppeteer in Creepypastas Characters.
+3-1Score: +2
Auli'i Cravalho
as Nina The Killer in Creepypastas Characters.
+3-1Score: +2
Lexi Rabe
as Sally Williams in Creepypastas Characters.
+6-0Score: +6
Charlie Plummer
as Ben Drowned in Creepypastas Characters.
+8-2Score: +6
Bill Skarsgård
as Jason The Toymaker in Creepypastas Characters.
+3-0Score: +3
Natalia Dyer
as Ani The Wight in Creepypastas Characters.
+3-1Score: +2
Sydney Sweeney
as Judge Angels in Creepypastas Characters.
+7-1Score: +6