Suggestions by @tylerwright

Patrick Gibson

as Oro in Lightlark

Patrick Stewart

as Oro in Lightlark

Danny DeVito

as Mayor of Halloween Town in Disney Universe

Eva Green

as Sally in Disney Universe

Benedict Cumberbatch

as Jack Skellington in Disney Universe

Josh Gad

as LeFou in As Old as Time

Kevin Kline

as Alaric Potts in As Old as Time

KJ Apa

as Prince Hans in Disney Universe

Grant Gustin

as Florian in Disney Universe

Shay Mitchell

as Pocahontas in Disney Universe

Lou Diamond Phillips

as Shan Yu in Disney Universe

Camila Mendes

as Snow White in Disney Universe

Charles Melton

as Shang in Disney Universe

Robbie Kay

as Peter Pan in Disney Universe

Ian Somerhalder

as Prince Eric in Disney Universe

Mehcad Brooks

as Prince Naveen in Disney Universe

Madelaine Petsch

as Anna in Disney Universe

Gugu Mbatha-Raw

as Tiana in Disney Universe

Colin O'Donoghue

as Captain Hook in Disney Universe

Reese Witherspoon

as Tinker Bell in Disney Universe