Suggestions by @trystanpainter

Karen Gillan

as Ruby roundhouse in Jumanji 4

Score: +1

Kevin Hart

as Franklin finbar in Jumanji 4

Score: +1

Jack Black

as Shelly oberon in Jumanji 4

Score: +1

Dwayne Johnson

as Smolder bravestone in Jumanji 4

Score: +1

Andrew Garfield

as Spider-Man in The Amazing Spider-Man 3

Score: +1

Steven Yeun

as Kyle rayner in Lanterns (HBO Series)

Score: +3

David Dastmalchian

as Podka-Dot Man in Booster Gold

Score: +1

Armie Hammer

as Guy Gardener in Booster Gold

Score: -1

Park Joo-bin

as Guy Gardener in Booster Gold

Score: -4

David Corenswet

as Superman in Booster Gold

Score: +2

Xolo Maridueña

as The Blue Beetle in Booster Gold

Score: +2

Jon Hamm

as Blue Beetle in Booster Gold

Score: -4

Nathan Fillion

as Booster Gold in Booster Gold

Score: -6

Paul Mescal

as Edward jones in Terminator

Score: +1

Rudy Pankow

as Connor Miller in Terminator

Score: +1

Peter Capaldi

as The Twelfth Doctor in Doctor Who: The Early-Revived Who

Score: 0

Matt Smith

as The Eleventh Doctor in Doctor Who: The Early-Revived Who

Score: 0

David Tennant

as The Tenth Doctor in Doctor Who: The Early-Revived Who

Score: +1